Balancing national security and right to know

Tshwane Principles launched after global consultations

Richard Lee's picture

Author

Strategic communications for WWF

June 12th, 2013

The question of how to ensure public access to government information without jeopardizing legitimate efforts to protect people from national security threats is the focus of a new set of global principles being unveiled today.

The  are the result of over two years of consultations around the world involving governments, former security officials, civil society organisations and academics, which were facilitated by the Open Society Justice Initiative and culminated in a recent meeting in Tshwane, South Africa.

The Principles address in unprecedented detail the balance between secrecy and the public’s right to know – in a world that has been transformed by global efforts to combat terrorism and the parallel rise of new digital technologies, as well as the rapid growth of right to information laws.

In addition to addressing what government-held information may legitimately be kept secret and what information should be disclosed, the Principles outline standards for the treatment of whistleblowers who act in the public interest, as well as issues related to classification and declassification, and other questions.

“The Principles are a major contribution to the right of access to information and the right to truth concerning human rights violations, and I believe they should be adopted by the Human Rights Council,” said Frank La Rue, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression. “All states should reflect these Principles in their interpretations of national security law.”

Developed by 22 academic and civil society groups – including 5 based in South Africa – who consulted over 500 experts from more than 70 countries, the Principles are based on a survey of international and national law, standards, good practices, and the writings of experts.

The process also involved working closely with the four special rapporteurs on freedom of expression and the media from the UN, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (ACHPR), the Organization of American States (OAS) and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), as well as with the UN Special Rapporteur on Counter-Terrorism and Human Rights.

“These Global Principles could not have come at a more opportune time, given the recent adoption of a model law on access to information for Africa by the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights,” said Pansy Tlakula, Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression and Access to Information in Africa. “These principles complement the provisions of the model law and also seek to strike the requisite balance between the public’s right to know and the protection of legitimate national security interests, given the current global context of rising insecurity. For my home country, South Africa, it would certainly come in quite handy, as we struggle to resolve all the thorny issues implicated in the recently adopted Protection of State Information Bill.”   

The Principles, in draft form, have already played a role in supporting civil society arguments to modify some of the most troubling sections of South Africa’s Protection of State Information Law, recently adopted by South Africa’s parliament but not yet signed by the president.

Some of the key principles in the final version include:

  • Information should be kept secret only if its disclosure poses “a real and identifiable risk of significant harm to a legitimate national security interest” (Principle 3);
  • Information concerning serious violations of international human rights or humanitarian law must always be disclosed (Principle 10A);
  • The public should have access to information on surveillance programmes (Principle 10E);
  • No government entity should be categorically exempt from disclosure requirements (Principle 5); and
  • Public officials who act in the public interest to expose government abuses should be protected from retaliation (Principle 40)

“The Tshwane Principles reflect global best practice in setting safeguards for balancing the protection of public interest disclosures and the disclosure of gross or systematic human rights violations against the need to maintain the secrecy of classified information,” said Ben Emmerson, UN Special Rapporteur on Counter-Terrorism and Human Rights. “I have no doubt that they will come to be regarded as a significant step in promoting international consistency on these sensitive and difficult questions.”

“My office welcomes the Tshwane Principles as the appropriate balance to ensure state capacity to protect security and the protection of individual freedoms,” said Catalina Botero, OAS Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression and Access to Information. “We must not lose sight of the fact that security, in a democratic society, is not an end in itself. Its only purpose is to protect the capacity of institutions to guarantee all people the free exercise of their rights, without discrimination. History has shown time and again that efforts to increase security through the suppression of liberty have threatened both liberty and security.”

 

Contacts

  • 1 Hood Avenue/148 Jan Smuts; Rosebank, GP 2196; South Africa
  • T. +27 (0)11 587 5000
  • F. +27 (0)11 587 5099